Description
The Illusione OneOff Black And Tan Toro is a 6 x 52 cigar with Nicaraguan wrapper, binder and filler, the second size in a blend that started as a 5 x 52 robusto. Aganorsa Leaf produces it in Nicaragua for Illusione owner Dion Giolito, per Cigar Aficionado and halfwheel.
What It Tastes Like
Cigar Aficionado scored this toro 94 points in a rating dated January 1, 2026, describing sweetness balanced by spice, with marzipan and white pepper alongside leather and grain, and placed it No. 20 on its Top 25 Cigars of 2025. Illusione’s own notes point to caramel, a flinty edge and an unusual spice on the finish. For the 5 x 52 robusto, halfwheel’s aged-sample redux centered on cocoa nibs and roasted peanuts.
Who It’s For
- Smokers who follow ratings and want the size Cigar Aficionado put on its 2025 Top 25.
- All-Nicaraguan blend fans curious about a leaf Giolito keeps unnamed.
- Robusto owners who liked the shorter OneOff Black and want an extra inch at the same ring.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- 94 points from Cigar Aficionado for this exact size
- Seco leaf from the fourth and fifth primings, rested in bales for three years, per Illusione and Cigar Coop
- Rolled at Aganorsa Leaf, which Cigar Aficionado calls one of Nicaragua’s biggest growers
Cons
- The seed variety stays undisclosed
- Strength descriptions vary from our mild-medium listing to medium-full
- Cigar Coop’s July 8, 2025 review of the 5 x 52 robusto scored 87, citing a tannic, astringent stretch
About the OneOff Black Line
Cigar Aficionado traces OneOff to Italian retailer Andrea Molinari in 2001; Giolito acquired the name in 2017 and relaunched it the next year. The Black And Tan robusto arrived in 2024, and a Cigar Aficionado story dated July 31, 2025 said the toro was shipping.
Compare Similar Cigars
- Illusione The Group of Five SE: also Aganorsa-rolled and all Nicaraguan, but fatter at 6 x 56.
- Illusione Epernay Tuonela Le Monde: same 52 ring at 6 1/4 inches, but Honduran-made under Mexican San Andrés leaf, per halfwheel and Cigar Coop.
- Illusione Original Documents Maduro Robusto: a shorter 5 x 52 swapping in a Mexican San Andres wrapper.
Illusione OneOff Black And Tan Toro FAQ
What size is the Illusione OneOff Black And Tan Toro?
This toro runs six inches by a 52 ring, as Cigar Aficionado, halfwheel and Cigar Coop each report.
Is OneOff Black the same cigar as OneOff Black And Tan?
Cigar Aficionado’s January 1, 2026 rating says the brand shortened the name from Black & Tan to just Black, and Illusione’s site now lists it as ONEOFF Black.
Who makes it?
Both Cigar Aficionado and halfwheel name Aganorsa Leaf in Nicaragua as the factory.
How strong is it?
Our listing says mild-medium; outside opinions run higher: Cigar Aficionado calls the toro medium-full, Cigar Coop rated the robusto medium, and halfwheel’s robusto reviews ranged from medium to medium-full.
See more Illusione cigars from Dion Giolito.
Additional information
| Packaging Type | Single |
|---|---|
| Origin | |
| Strength | Mild-Medium |
| Wrapper | Nicaragua |
| Binder | Nicaraguan |
| Filler | Nicaraguan |
| Length | 6" |
| Gauge | 52 |

There are no reviews yet.